10 Best Hotels In Key Largo To Check Out

Of all the states within the US, Florida has to be one of the most popular and highly visited in the entire country.

10 Best Hotels In Key Largo To Check Out

One of the most popular places within the state is Key Largo – a popular destination located on the Florida Keys, and one that has much to offer both locals and tourists alike (see also “Best Places To Eat In Destin Florida“). 

But where are the best hotels to try in Key Largo, and what makes them so special?

Where Is Key Largo?

Key Largo is an island located in the upper archipelago of the Florida Keys – and acts as the largest section of habitable land in this region. 

A popular tourist destination, Key Largo is perhaps best known for its diving – where people come from miles around to enjoy some of the best diving spots in the country.

As well as this, it is also a popular destination for those looking to kick back, experience some great weather, and check out the breathtaking natural beauty of the region.

The Best Hotels In Key Largo

Now that we know a little more about Key Largo, it is now time to more closely examine the best hotels in the area – each of them offering something a little different and special to those vacationing on the island. 

So, without further ado, let’s get started!

1. Baker’s Cay Resort – 4 Star

First on our list, we have the Baker’s Cay resort – a hotel that offers something a little more wholesome, homely, and different to the average chain hotel. 

The hotel itself is adorned in natural wood finishes, light, natural colors, and with all the aesthetic beauty one could need to enjoy the beautiful scenery wherein the hotel resides.

Offering staggering views of the ocean, this hotel really feels like it is at the end of the world – offering privacy and peace to those lucky enough to stay. 


  • Charming decor
  • Ocean views
  • Private 


  • Somewhat overpriced

Address: 97000 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL 33037-2210

2. Hampton Inn, Key Largo – 4 Star

Next on our list we have the Hampton Inn at Key Largo – a great entry from a trustworthy and much loved hotel chain within the United States. 

What the Hampton Inn offers is peace, quiet, and all the amenities you will need to relax and take in the bounty that nature has provided to this beautiful oasis within the Keys. 

The hotel really feels like an extension of the beach front itself, offering natural wood finishes, tasteful colors and materials, and each room perfectly designed to maximize comfort, facilitate relaxation, and create the perfect launchpad for your Key Largo vacation. 


  • Peaceful and quiet
  • Clean rooms
  • Friendly staff
  • Beachfront location


  • Somewhat dated rooms

Address: 102400 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL 33037-2747

3. Bay Harbor Lodge – 4 Star

Next we have the Bay Harbor Lodge – a charming hotel offering spacious, clean rooms that provide plenty of space to relax, find your center, and recharge for your Key Largo vacation. 

With a distinctive decor style that pays homage to the Caribbean islands that sit nestled just across the sea, this hotel really embodies island life – encouraging relaxation, comfort, and peace above all else. 


  • Spacious clean rooms
  • Charming decor
  • Peaceful and private


  • Lacking amenities

Address: 97702 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037-2297

4. Amoray Dive Resort – 4 Star

While the Amoray Dive Resort might seem basic on the face of things, what it really offers is a cozy, comfortable, clean, and relaxing place for you to recharge, find some peace, and plan your Key Largo itinerary. 

Focusing on the important things, rather than gimmicks and aesthetics, this hotel offers something refreshingly subtle and attractive for the hotel-going traveler. 


  • Cozy and comfortable
  • Clean rooms
  • Subtle and laid back


  • Somewhat disorganized

Address: 104250 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL 33037

5. Playa Largo Resort & Spa – 4 Star

Luxurious, tasteful, elegant: these are all words you could use to describe the Playa Largo Resort & Spa, and go some way to explain why people continue to come back year after year. 

If you are looking for the elegance and class of high society living, then this is really the place for you, offering a peaceful, stylish, and comfortable hotel that has all the amenities and style you could ever want. 


  • Classy and elegant
  • Stylish, comfortable rooms


  • Some customer service issues

Address: 97450 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL 33037-2209

6. Island Bay Resort – 5 Star

For those seeking peace, quiet, and relaxation, you would do well to find somewhere better than the Island Bay Resort.

Nestled in its own private cove, this hotel is more like a series of private bungalows, giving you all the privacy and comfort you need to enjoy your time there to the fullest. 

But that is not to say that you will be alone while you are there – and in fact Island Bay really has a communal feel that allows those looking for friends and entertainment to find it with ease. 


  • Peaceful and quiet location
  • Comfortable and clean
  • Plenty of communal activities 
  • Perfect for relaxing


  • 2 night minimum policy

Address: 92530 Overseas Highway, Tavernier, Key Largo, FL 33070-2758

7. Seafarer Resort & Beach – 4 Star

As an island destination, Key Largo has its fair share of beach resort hotels – each of them offering up something a little different to the lucky guests who stay there.

When it comes to the Seafarer Resort & Beach, what you are really getting is a down to Earth, rustic experience of island life that you will never forget. 

With numerous amenities, activities, and sights to be seen in the local area, this really is a great pit stop for those looking to experience Key Largo without breaking the bank. 


  • Down to Earth
  • Charming and clean
  • Numerous amenities
  • Affordable price


  • Hard to make phone enquiries 

Address: 97684 Overseas Hwy MM 97.6 Bayside, Key Largo, FL 33037-2214

8. Reef House Resort & Marina – 4 Star

For those seeking a lively, communal resort, then the Reef House Resort & Marina might just be the one for you.

This is everything you would expect from a beach resort and more, offering all the amenities you could ever want in a charming, elegant setting that is perfect for meeting new people and trying something new. 

Take in cocktails and drinks at the extravagant hotel bar, or retire to the pool area for refreshments and relaxation.

This really is a great place to kick back and relax on vacation, and offers the perfect base camp for those looking to explore further afield. 


  • Good amenities 
  • Charming and elegant setting
  • Perfect for relaxation
  • Clean rooms


  • Somewhat overpriced

Address: 103800 Overseas Highway, Key Largo, FL 33037

9. Bungalows Key Largo – 4 Star

What could possibly be more relaxing than a charming, peaceful oceanside bungalow?

Luckily, you only need to check into the Bungalows Key Largo to find the answer to this question – giving you the perfect place to unwind, relax, and find a little peace on your Key Largo vacation. 

This perfectly combines class, elegance, comfort, and wholesomeness – ensuring that everyone has all the tools they need to create their own little slice of paradise right in the heart of Key Largo. 


  • Charming and peaceful 
  • Clean and comfortable 
  • Elegant environment


  • Some hidden charges

Address: 99010 Overseas Hwy, Key Largo, FL 33037-2452

10. Kona Kai Resort – 5 Star

Last but not least, the Kona Kai Resort offers the perfect pitstop for your travels around Key Largo – creating an incredibly comfortable, relaxing aesthetic. . 

This hotel focuses more on creating a homely, relaxing vibe, and it leaves all the other gimmicks and unnecessary features at the door.

What remains is a hotel that feels like a home away from home, giving you the perfect place to experience the beauty of the local environment, and the perfect base camp to recharge after a long day exploring. 


  • Homely, charming decor
  • Comforting environment
  • Perfect for relaxation


  • Needs updating somewhat

Address: 97802 Overseas Highway Mm 98, Key Largo, FL 33037-2229

Final Thoughts

It’s true that the state of Florida has much to offer both tourists and locals alike – with the region of Key Largo offering more than most.

With sights, sounds, activities, and some of the best natural beauty spots in the country, it really does have it all.

So if you are headed to Key Largo, then be sure to check out these great hotels (see also “Best Hotels In Sarasota FL“).

Frequently Asked Questions

Now that we know all about the best hotels in Key Largo, it is now time to check out some frequently asked questions that you might be interested in.

Is Key Largo Expensive?

While activities and entertainment can soon hike up the price, Key Largo is generally cheaper than many of the other locations in the region – such as Key West.

When Is The Best Time To Visit?

The best months to visit Key Largo – in terms of the weather – are January, February, March, April, May, October, November, and December.

Julia Wright
Scroll to Top